Secret Ingredient Recipes

You'll never guess what makes these recipes so special and delicious!

Staff Picks

David's Secret Ingredient Chocolate Chip Cookies

Rating: 4 stars 56
A much better version of the traditional tollhouse cookie. No one will ever guess what the secret ingredient is.

Mock Coconut Pie (Spaghetti Squash Pie)

Rating: 4.5 stars 202
Not too many people would know this pie is not made with coconut, but actually uses spaghetti squash. I wasn't sure what to do with a bumper crop of spaghetti squash and this quickly became an annual answer to a now non-issue!

Janie's Amazing Smoothie

Rating: 4.5 stars 21
This is a low calorie smoothie that tastes great! It helps keep you full, so it's great for dieters and it's lactose free!

Cola Pot Roast II

Rating: 4.5 stars 1020
The rich brown gravy this makes is wonderful, with just a slight hint of sweetness. Everyone asks for the recipe, and NO ONE ever guesses the secret ingredient...cola!

Two-Ingredient Pizza Dough

Rating: 4.5 stars 273
Greek yogurt is the secret ingredient in this two-ingredient pizza crust recipe that is quick and easy to prepare.

3-Ingredient Cake Mix Cobbler

Rating: 4.5 stars 39
Yummy peach cobbler made with cake mix. It makes you feel as though you are in the South on a warm sunny day. This recipe is inexpensive, easy, and surprisingly delicious!

Barbie's Tuna Salad

Rating: 4.5 stars 2287
This is a really great tuna salad recipe I got from a friend who used it in her catering service business many years ago. The secret ingredients are the curry and Parmesan cheese! Odd combinations but this makes a terrific tuna sandwich! She used it for an appetizer with gourmet crackers and people always wanted her recipe. I have never tasted another tuna salad quite like this one, and it has been my favorite recipe for tuna salad for many, many years.
By TANAQUIL

Real NY Jewish Rye Bread

Rating: 5 stars 249
For thousands of years man has been enjoying bread. This rye bread recipe will add to this ancient enjoyment. Having lived in northwest Connecticut for over 35 years, in close proximity to NYC with its great Jewish delis, baking some of the finest rye bread going, I snagged this recipe from a friend. Hope you like it. Enjoy and share with your family, friends, and neighbors.

Mother-In-Law Eggs

Rating: 4.5 stars 135
Sugar and hot mustard are the secret ingredients in this much-requested recipe for deviled eggs. Whenever my daughter-in-law throws a party, she is always asked, 'Are you having your mother-in-law's eggs?' Mothers-in-law are known to be sweet and devilish!

Chef John's Dark Chocolate Mousse

Rating: 4.5 stars 94
This has a pinch of chile pepper as the secret ingredient. It's firm yet unbelievably light and airy. The little bit of chile pepper is in there just to bring out the flavor of the chocolate and add a tiny bit of delicious heat. Garnish each serving with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of shaved chocolate.

Almond Flour Bread

Rating: 4.5 stars 170
This is a delicious grain-free bread made out of almond flour that is high in protein and low in carbohydrates.

Mom's Best Spaghetti Sauce

Rating: 4 stars 130
A simple, slow cooked, authentic spaghetti sauce, as good as the restaurants serve...or better! The secret ingredient is baking soda, but do not taste the sauce right after adding it. Wait a while, and this sauce will not disappoint you. It is good right from the stove, but the flavors blend overnight. Best served with your favorite meatball recipe, where the meatballs cook in the sauce the last half hour. Be prepared to take a nap after eating.
By KRAZYBARB
Advertisement

Inspiration and Ideas

12 Irresistible Recipes With Saltines You'll Make Again and Again
These crave-worthy recipes share a secret ingredient that you probably already have on hand: saltine crackers!
15 Delicious Ways to Use Instant Coffee
Just a pinch of the powerful ingredient deepens and enhances rich flavors — particularly chocolate.
Fettuccine with Creamy Roasted Beet Sauce
Rating: 5 stars 6

A vegetarian fettuccine dish made with a delicious nightshade-free pasta sauce.