Leftover Candy Recipes

Got an extra-big haul from trick-or-treating? Put leftover treats to good use in these recipes for candy corn bark, snack mix, candy bar fudge, and candy bar cakes.

Staff Picks

Halloween Candy Blondies

Transform your leftover Halloween candy into gooey blondie bars. These bars pair perfectly with ice cream or a hot or cold beverage of your choice.
By Sandra Garth

Crispy Rice Candy Corn Treats

Rating: 4.63 stars
6
A fun change to the usual gooey treats that we all love. Make some for the fall!
By willbake4shoes

Leftover Halloween Candy Brownies!

Rating: 4.53 stars
14
Scrumptious, soft, blonde brownie recipe filled with M&M's®, Butterfinger®, Reese's®, Hershey's®, and others! You will enjoy every bite! Feel free to use any variety of candy!
By pastrygoddess31797

Peanutty Candy Corn Cereal Bars

Rating: 4.71 stars
4
The salty taste of the peanuts and peanut butter mixes well with the sweetness of candy corn. A fast and easy treat for Halloween or Thanksgiving.
By NICOLEGARDNER

Milky Way® Cupcake Icing

Rating: 4.2 stars
57
This is an excellent icing that I use on my yellow cupcakes.
By House of Aqua

Snickers® Brownies

Rating: 4.75 stars
3
These brownies are a great way to use up some of that leftover Halloween candy! These are made with Snickers® bars, but you can substitute Milky Way® candy bars for a different variation.
By fabeveryday

Banana Royale

Rating: 4.8 stars
9
A caramel-nougat candy bar stuffed into bananas, wrapped in foil and roasted in the coals for a super rich camping treat! These are really rich and a fun treat for camping that's different than S'mores.
By Bethany Dasko

Chocolate Candy Bar Cake

Rating: 4.82 stars
214
I made this once for a family gathering and now everyone insists that it be at every gathering! It's so easy; you use a box cake mix! For chopping the chocolate bars, I put them in the freezer, then hit them with a hammer while still in the wrapper
By NOUELLETTE

Deep Fried Candy Bars

Rating: 4.17 stars
5
A Scotland favorite. Deep-fried candy bars such as Milky Way®, Snickers®, Mars® Bars, etc. We like Snickers® the best. A real treat! This recipe is my own variation. Enjoy!
By craftgal1

Chocolate Rice Pudding

Rating: 4.12 stars
12
A very quick and creamy dessert that can be made with leftover rice from last night's dinner.
By Dannielle Lalonde

Broiler S'mores

Rating: 4.96 stars
39
I'll admit making s'mores over a campfire is the best method, but, if your living with a statewide burn ban and don't have a fireplace, this is a fabulous alternative. On the up side, this method does produce perfectly uniform, golden marshmallows.
By MPADEN

Candy Bar Salad

Rating: 4.62 stars
11
This is a favorite recipe in our family. I got this from a friend for my mom to make when I was a child. Now I always make it for potlucks where there will be lots of kids there. This salad does not keep well, so be sure to make it the day you are serving.
By ASERGEANTSWIFE
Advertisement

Inspiration and Ideas

Candy Corn Bark

Candy Corn Bark
"Spectacular! Very sweet, but I could not stop eating it. I lined my pan with wax paper, and pressed the candy down with more wax paper. Great!" – PULLEYHEATHER
Monster Munch Halloween Popcorn Mix

Monster Munch Halloween Popcorn Mix
"What a fun way to use up leftover candy from Halloween!" – mis7up
Easy Butter Fingers Candy

Easy Butter Fingers Candy
Peanutty Candy Corn Cereal Bars

Peanutty Candy Corn Cereal Bars
Peanut Candy Bar Cake

Peanut Candy Bar Cake
Rating: Unrated
43
Peanut-Butterfinger Cream Pie

Peanut-Butterfinger Cream Pie
Rating: Unrated
12

Mini Candy Bar Cookies

Rating: 4.33 stars
14

Delicious cookie recipe with mini candy bars wrapped in a quick dough made from cake mix. This is a recipe passed down from a dear friend who would make these for her son when he was deployed to Iraq.

More Leftover Candy Recipes

Chocolate Covered Peppermint Patties

Rating: 4.36 stars
82
These cool peppermint patties are made with mashed potatoes.
By Wendy MacLeod

Candy Bar Brownies

Rating: 4.24 stars
96
Brownies made with candy bars.
By Madonna

Easy Butter Fingers Candy

Rating: 4.46 stars
29
Sometimes I am embarrassed to tell people how easy this delicious candy is to make. It tastes very much like a famous crunchy peanut candy bar, and can be made in about 10 minutes (total time)! I like to buy a lot candy corn right after Halloween when it is on sale so it can be a very inexpensive candy to make. Sometimes I drizzle some melted milk chocolate on top of the semisweet chocolate after it's cooled just for decoration.
By Kelli Stovall

Chocolate Buttermilk Layer Cake

Rating: 4.69 stars
13
Buttermilk is beloved in recipes for its ability to make rich, moist cakes. This chocolate buttermilk layer cake uses a variety of your favorite chopped candy bars sprinkled between each layer and as a coating for a sweet, crunchy surprise. This will quickly become a family favorite.
By Butterfinger
Sponsored By Butterfinger

Spider Cupcakes

Rating: 4.55 stars
68
These are a huge hit with kids!
By Heatherly Noble

Candy Corn Bark

Rating: 4.4 stars
156
A delightful recipe only for those with a incurable sweet tooth! Candy corn mixed with chocolate sandwich cookies and pretzels will please your whole Halloween crowd.
By Julie G

Dairy-Free Coconut Candy Bar Ice Cream

Rating: 4.14 stars
5
This ice cream is great for lactose intolerant or dairy-allergic people.
By dana

Candy Bar Fudge

Rating: 4.61 stars
59
This fudge was included in my Christmas treats that I took to the teachers at school. It was the first to be gone, and I had lots of requests for the recipe!
By PATTY STOCKTON

Kit Kat® Bundt® Cake

Rating: 3.67 stars
3
I always have tons of Halloween candy from my kids and this is a great way to use up Kit Kats®. I served this at Thanksgiving for those who didn't want pie. Everybody loved this cake. Frosting will be like a syrup but will thicken as it cools.
By KELSEYANDTYLERSMOMMY

Candy Bar Popcorn

Rating: 4.05 stars
15
Popcorn and Snickers™ - a much-too-easy yummy treat! Of course you can substitute the Snickers™ with any variety of meltable candy bars. It's the sweet and salty combination that you want!
By VETTECHICK99

Halloween Popcorn Hands

Rating: 5 stars
4
An easy snack, perfect for Halloween parties. Clear plastic gloves are stuffed with candy corn and popcorn to make a salty-sweet surprise!
By ellbell19

Spook-tacular Chocolate-Dipped Pretzels

Dipped in melted chocolate morsels and decorated with a variety of spookalicious candies, these festive treats are a frightfully fun way to celebrate the haunting night ahead.
By Butterfinger
Sponsored By Butterfinger

Candy-Bar Fudge

Rating: 4.2 stars
4
This is a recipe that I found years ago and it was made with Milky Way® bars and I changed it. I have used Snickers®, 3 Musketeers®, Milky Way®, etc. My kids love this.
By Jennifer Griffin Lord

Candy Bar Pie II

Rating: 4.29 stars
10
Layers of chocolate, cream cheese, and nuts .... a crowd pleasing pie good for any occasion.
By Vickie

Candy Bar Squares

Rating: 4.38 stars
5
This recipe is a basic bar cookie recipe that you can add your favorite chocolate covered candy bars to.
By Linda Michael

S'more Eyeballs

Rating: 5 stars
3
A deliciously spooky treat that is easy to make and the kids love! Get s'more eyeballs before they are gone; these get eaten quickly!
By arenee83

Leftover Halloween Candy Cookies

Rating: 2 stars
2
Do you have tons of leftover Halloween candy bars to get rid of? You can use pretty much any chocolate candy bar: Snickers®, Milky Way®, Heath®, Almond Joy®, Rolos®, chocolate bars, etc. Whatever candy you use, these cookies will taste just like them!
By w

Butterfinger S'mores

These oven-made Butterfinger S'mores are easy to make and your kids will love them.
By Butterfinger
Sponsored By Butterfinger

Candy Bar Pie I

Rating: 4.33 stars
1
This pie really does taste like a slice of a big candy bar and it melts in your mouth when you bite in.
By Stephanie

Trick or Treat Cheesecake

Rating: 3.67 stars
1
A rich treat that will get many compliments. You can add just about any candy bar combination. Let your imagination run wild. I used the Halloween cookies with orange filling; the flavor is still the same. Before serving, carefully remove sides of pan and place on a serving dish. I added candy corn on top before serving.
By luv2bake

Chunky Halloween Candy Cookies

Rating: 4.5 stars
1
What do you do with all of that Halloween candy? Make these fabulous cookies of course! Leftover halloween candy and a chewy cookie recipe serve up quickly and taste oh-so-delicious. This also works great with Easter candy too.
By KMOMMYZ
Advertisement
© Copyright . All rights reserved. Printed from https://www.allrecipes.com