Buffalo, NY Recipes

Looking for Buffalo, New York recipes? Allrecipes has more than 50 trusted Buffalo, New York recipes complete with ratings, reviews and cooking tips.

Staff Picks

Garlic Parmesan Wing Sauce

Rating: Unrated
123
Zesty copy of Buffalo Wild Wings® sauce.

Bocconcini Salad

Rating: Unrated
13
Bite-size balls of fresh mozzarella, known as bocconcini, make up this great salad. If possible, seek out mozzarella di bufala, made from water buffalo's milk; a specialty of central and southern Italy, it is a softer, creamier mozzarella than that made from cow's milk.

Grilled Blue Cheese Pears

Rating: Unrated
19
Had some pears that needed to be used up, so we threw them on the BBQ. They taste great with pork chops (a little like an applesauce texture!) or even to accompany BBQ buffalo wings! The blue cheese is a nice pairing!
Sponsored By [object Object]

Basil Pan-Seared Scallops over Pasta

Rating: Unrated
73
This dish is so easy to make, but tastes like you slaved away in the kitchen. When purchasing the scallops, be sure to look for a subtle pink or creme color. Stark white scallops have been soaked in water to add extra weight. Other pastas such as rotini, shells, or penne can be substituted for the farfalle. Makes an excellent main course, or add spinach or asparagus to turn it into a meal in itself. My pookie likes to have this dish served with antipasto of buffalo mozzarella, artichoke hearts, and fire roasted tomatoes.

Buffalo Cauliflower

Rating: Unrated
227
This is a great substitution for buffalo wings! Can be made gluten-free, vegan, or vegetarian. Make sure to coat your cookie sheet well with oil or they will stick. Husband and kids give this two thumbs up! Dip this in ranch or blue cheese for even more added flavor, but it doesn't need it.

Slow Cooker Root Beer Pulled Pork

Rating: Unrated
27
This simple slow cooker pulled pork recipe is big hit with my family of picky eaters. For a spicy kick, mix 1 part Frank's® RedHot® Buffalo sauce and 1 part of your favorite mustard-based BBQ sauce. You can use a pork loin instead of pork shoulder, if desired. Combine with your favorite BBQ sauce and enjoy.

Homemade Taco Seasoning Mix

Rating: Unrated
352
Much lower salt than pre-made. Salt can be omitted. Great with half ground buffalo and half ground turkey breast or whatever you prefer. Buy bulk spices and you can make 5-plus batches for under $1.00!! Increasing black pepper and adding optional ingredients will increase heat. Using mild or regular chili powder and omitting optional ingredients will reduce heat. To keep salt content low make sure chili powder does not contain salt.

Gochujang Sauce

Rating: Unrated
6
I use this sauce in many of the Asian dishes I make. It's fantastic on wings instead of traditional buffalo wing sauce.

Buffalo Shrimp

Rating: Unrated
268
This is the BEST...you can adjust the intensity of the buffalo sauce to your liking. We like it HOT!!

Beef on Weck

Rating: Unrated
21
An easy roast beef sandwich with local origins in Buffalo, New York. Kimmelweck rolls are hard kaiser-type rolls covered in coarse ground salt and caraway seeds. This recipe transforms regular rolls into the traditional weck rolls.

Rule of 3 - Garlic Buffalo Wing Sauce

Rating: Unrated
7
Easy and delicious buffalo wing sauce. Coat wings prepared in desired method - I prefer them deep-fried and crispy.

The Perfect Buffalo Wing Sauce

Rating: Unrated
3
Not too mild, but not too hot. Great for BBQs or picnics. Once sauce is bubbling, turn to low and let fried wings sit in sauce for 5 minutes flipping wings every other minute. Serve and enjoy! Don't forget the celery sticks and blue cheese.

Inspiration and Ideas

Bacon-Wrapped Pickles

Rating: Unrated
14
You can pretty much wrap anything in bacon, including pickles! These are perfect for game day or any time of year. Thick-cut bacon doesn't work as well for these, so use the thinner slices. Serve with ranch or blue cheese dressing. These are also tasty dipped in Buffalo sauce.

Cheeseburger Quesadilla

Rating: Unrated
8
Burritoville, a local joint down by Southeast University here, specializes in some of the oddest burritos I've ever tasted. From the BBQ chicken to the Buffalo burrito, I've had them all, but they've got only one type of quesadilla. So I've decided to take one of my favorite burritos from there, the cheeseburger burrito and apply it to quesadilla form. Served with a side of fries and a Coke®, it's what I call my most recent of culinary triumphs. Serve with a side of ketchup, yellow mustard, and sweet relish.

Buffalo Sauce

Rating: Unrated
37

Dip chicken wings and tenders in this spicy, red sauce. Be sure to have plenty of ranch-style dressing, blue cheese and celery sticks on hand!