Pirate Theme Recipes

Avast there, matey! Gentlemen of Fortune, pet parrots, and landlubbers alike will love these pirate-themed recipes.

Staff Picks

Captain's Vacation

Rating: 4.28 stars
25
This is a really easy tropical-style drink recipe for all you spiced rum fans out there. You can garnish it with some pineapple chunks or one of those little toothpick umbrellas.

Treasure Cookies

Rating: 4.48 stars
71
My niece gave me this recipe.

Long Johns

Rating: 3.87 stars
15
These doughnuts are a classic breakfast item. Flavor your glaze with chocolate or maple spread for different flavors.

Seafarer's Newburg

Rating: 4.4 stars
5
Shrimp in a creamy white sauce served over tater tots. Yum!

Pirate Stew

Rating: 3.83 stars
18
This beef stew for the slow cooker has a taste of the Caribbean (brown sugar and rum) that your whole family will love. This recipe is my own creation and uses primarily root vegetables from the ship's hold. Let this cook while you and the crew take on another adventure.

Shipwreck Dinner

Rating: 4.46 stars
80
It's not pretty but, it's a tasty, busy-night, kid-friendly meal. It's not 'gourmet,' but it's hot filling and easy. The prep time is generally limited to how fast your can opener works and how hard it is to unwrap your meat. The big bonus is that it's a complete one-pot meal with no chopping, unless you want to.

Green Grog

Rating: 4.52 stars
197
We like to call it the green drink. It's sweet, it's sour, it's tasty and it packs a real punch so go slow.

Shipwreck Stew

Rating: 3.86 stars
50
This recipe is a wonderful, hearty meal for those cool Autumn days. Great for feeding friends on football Sundays.

Captain Crunch Chicken

Rating: 3.81 stars
72
This is a 'sweet' change from the same old bread crumb breading! Simple, sweet and crrrrunchy!

Captain Duarte's Salt Cod Cakes

Rating: 4.49 stars
37
Based on my father-in-laws recipe, these fish cakes use salt cod. Trust me, it is worth the effort to find the salt cod. The slight saltiness of the cod brings out a whole new dimension of flavor. Who knows fish better than a Portuguese fishing Capt? Even Emeril would be proud! Serve with a good tartar sauce.

The Captain's Cannonball

Rating: 4.4 stars
5
I have recently found a love for mixology and experimenting with new and wild alcohol flavors. Substitute diet soda if desired.

Grandma Flo's Shipwreck

Rating: 3.81 stars
78
You can't go wrong with meat and potatoes, and this recipe combines them in one dish. The recipe was given to my husband by a friend at work who brought it for lunch often. I usually double it for my family; my husband works in a giant tire factory, and has an appetite to match. The smell makes it hard to wait for it to finish baking.
Advertisement

Inspiration and Ideas

Rolled Buttercream Fondant
Rating: Unrated
749
Perfect for decorating pirate cupcakes, a pirate ship cake, and treasure chest cookies!
Pirate's Last Call
Rating: Unrated
17
Yo-ho-ho, and a bottle of rum! This one's for the grownups.

Country Captain Chicken with Rice

Rating: 4.25 stars
4

This is an easy dish to experiment with Indian cooking, assuming it is not a family tradition already. I learned it from my sous chef Robbie J. at Keswick Hall.