The cake itself is very moist and my family loved it. The frosting didn't turn out so well for me. It was like sticky hard candy/burnt sugar . I found it difficult to chew and it wasn't very peanut buttery by that time. It's possible it was under the broiler too long, but I did follow the directions to place it under broiler until brown and bubbly. Either way, I scraped off the frosting and made another peanut butter frosting recipe from the site that was more conventional and pleased the family. Great cake and super easy! Thanks.