Great Halloween cake! You'll need a new kitty litter box, box liner and litter scoop as props to get the full effect with this cake!

Dee
Advertisement

Ingredients

20
Original recipe yields 20 servings
The ingredient list now reflects the servings specified
Ingredient Checklist

Directions

Instructions Checklist
  • Prepare cake mixes and bake according to package directions (any size pan).

    Advertisement
  • Prepare pudding according to package directions and chill until ready to assemble.

  • Crumble sandwich cookies in small batches in a food processor, scraping often. Set aside all but 1/4 cup. To the 1/4 cup add a few drops of green food coloring and mix.

  • When cakes are cooled to room temperature, crumble them into a large bowl. Toss with 1/2 of the remaining cookie crumbs, and the chilled pudding. You probably won't need all of the pudding, you want the cake to be just moist, not soggy.

  • Line kitty litter box with the kitty litter liner. Put cake mixture into box.

  • Put half of the unwrapped tootsie rolls in a microwave safe dish and heat until softened. Shape the ends so that they are no longer blunt, and curve the tootsie rolls slightly. Bury tootsie rolls randomly in the cake and sprinkle with half of the remaining cookie crumbs. Sprinkle a small amount of the green colored cookie crumbs lightly over the top.

  • Heat 3 or 4 of the tootsie rolls in the microwave until almost melted. Scrape them on top of the cake and sprinkle lightly with some of the green cookie crumbs. Heat the remaining tootsie rolls until pliable and shape as before. Spread all but one randomly over top of cake mixture. Sprinkle with any remaining cookie crumbs. Hang the remaining tootsie roll over side of litter box and sprinkle with a few green cookie crumbs. Serve with the pooper scooper for a gross Halloween dessert.

Nutrition Facts

351.2 calories; protein 3.4g 7% DV; carbohydrates 76.6g 25% DV; fat 7.5g 12% DV; cholesterolmg; sodium 592.9mg 24% DV. Full Nutrition

Reviews (410)

Read More Reviews

Most helpful positive review

Rating: 5 stars
10/31/2005
what a wonderful joke delicious too!!I've made this twice now.I bought the smallest cat box I could find and the first time it barely covered the bottom. The second time I made up 2 vanilla cake mixes and one chocolate and it filled the pan alot better.Also the second time I added the pudding before it set and it was alot easier to mix.It was a big hit both times however got lots of laughs.I would love to meet the twisted mind who first thought it up...genius. Read More
(333)

Most helpful critical review

Rating: 3 stars
10/28/2003
Overall this recipe was a great effect. It really "grossed" everybody out but it really was tasty. But it wasn't as realistic on the first try so I made some changes to the recipe. First I got rid of the chocolate cake mix and opted for another white mix. Then I used Oreo cookies instead of vanilla creams. I still used a few vanilla creams with the green food coloring mixed in. And lastly I sprinkled the whole thing with powdered sugar to mimic the baking soda that lots of folks put in their litter boxes. Read More
(102)
486 Ratings
  • 5 star values: 350
  • 4 star values: 103
  • 3 star values: 25
  • 2 star values: 3
  • 1 star values: 5
Rating: 5 stars
10/31/2005
what a wonderful joke delicious too!!I've made this twice now.I bought the smallest cat box I could find and the first time it barely covered the bottom. The second time I made up 2 vanilla cake mixes and one chocolate and it filled the pan alot better.Also the second time I added the pudding before it set and it was alot easier to mix.It was a big hit both times however got lots of laughs.I would love to meet the twisted mind who first thought it up...genius. Read More
(333)
Rating: 5 stars
10/30/2006
I have found when doing this cake that the plastic liner makes it tough to scoop so I do not use the liner for the recipe. Read More
(295)
Rating: 5 stars
06/20/2007
We laughed the entire time making this cake. We couldn't believe how "real" it looked! We followed others advice: no liner peanut butter sandwich cookies cheese cake pudding and crushed up butterfinger bars in cake. Use the 4 inch long tootsie rolls and mircrowave for about 15-20 seconds. Let them set a few minutes and then take off the plate. They only needed a little shaping. It ended up tasting pretty good! You will never have more fun making a cake! Read More
(247)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
10/28/2007
Got gross reviews and that's what it's meant for right!? This is the second time I've made this and to make it more tasteful I used two boxes Marble cake mix and two chocolate ready made pudding containers. I also used a tub of Creamy Fudge frosting which I microwaved and mixed with the pudding. This definitely moistened it and made it taste more like "chocolate cake" than dried cake with some pudding globs. I took the leftover frosting and drizzled on top of the cake before putting the cookie crumbs on it. You could use any type of cake mix and frosting because it's basically hidden underneath the cookie crumbs anyway. Read More
(111)
Rating: 3 stars
10/28/2003
Overall this recipe was a great effect. It really "grossed" everybody out but it really was tasty. But it wasn't as realistic on the first try so I made some changes to the recipe. First I got rid of the chocolate cake mix and opted for another white mix. Then I used Oreo cookies instead of vanilla creams. I still used a few vanilla creams with the green food coloring mixed in. And lastly I sprinkled the whole thing with powdered sugar to mimic the baking soda that lots of folks put in their litter boxes. Read More
(102)
Rating: 5 stars
10/12/2007
I served this tonight at my girl scout troop's halloween party and it was a huge hit. The pan is almost empty. The cake tasted great and was perfect for the kids but of course the real knock-out was the way it looked. It was truly disgusting and had the parents gagging and snickering. I used Little Debbie brownies rolled into poop-shapes instead of tootsie rolls which I thought would harden too easily. They looked even more realistic than the tootsie rolls. I also used an entire cup of cookie crumbs dyed green for the topping and it looked really authentic. Great recipe! Read More
(98)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
10/17/2005
This was the most creative cake Iv ever seen! I made this for my husband to take to work today he called me at noon and said everyone was cracking up and loved it. I didnt use a liner and it still looked fabulous. I did crush up a Butterfinger and add it to the mix for some extra flavor. I used 4 vanilla snack packs and it was the perfect amount! Read More
(55)
Rating: 5 stars
10/29/2003
I "serve" this cake up every year for our Halloween Party and will be doing so again this year! Props totally make the cake! I really go for the gross-out effect and roll some of the pooh in the cookie crumbles. Not the tastiest cake but the effect is what does it. Got a great photo last year of my cat peeking into the pan (while everyone ran to keep her out!)! Thanks Dee for always making my Halloween Party a hit! Read More
(49)
Rating: 4 stars
10/18/2006
Fun cake to make tastes okay but most people wouldn't get near it. A lot of work for something almost no one would try. Couldn't get past how gross it looked I guess. Terrific for Halloween or any time you want high "gross out factor" but expect it to be decorative not dessert. Read More
(41)