This was good but it kind of separated out on me a little due to the long simmering time after the addition of the flour. If I were to do it again I would just add the flour and broth to the veggies let that cook until the taters were tender and then add the milk and let it thicken up. When I first added the milk it had a beautiful texture but broke up with all the simmering. I simmered at a low temp too. I used one Yukon Gold and one red potato. I used a mix of skim milk and fat-free evaporated milk and added a bit of both extra milk and broth. Omitted the wine. I cut the cheese down to 1 cup. It was very rich and creamy even with the skim milk. Served with focaccia bread.
This was a wonderful recipe. It smelled so wonderful. I did make a few changes in it though as I made it. I used about 1/2 cup wine. I added 1/4 tsp cracked red pepper. I also used I stalk of green onion instead of chives. I made this with a friend and we finished it the same night. I hope you enjoy making this as well as eating it.
I read through the reviews before I made this soup finding WhatADish's review quite helpful so I made one minor change regarding the milk. I didn't add it until right before I took it off the heat right after I added the cheese. I also did not add a whole cup and cup and a half. I used about a quarter cup or so just to give it a touch of creaminess. Next time I make this I'd use different spices I think. I just wasn't a fan of the spices in this soup but that's really just personal preferance. I think I'd add chunked ham too. Oh! When I sauteed the onion I also added a mess of fresh minced garlic.
Very delicious! I made a couple of adjustments - I toasted some minced garlic and added to the mixture while it was simmering. I also cut down the amount of cheese. I thought the full amount would overwhelm the other flavors of the soup. I will definitely make this again - maybe add some bacon next time.
Awesome recipe!!!! We all LOVED IT!!!
Very good. Followed recipe exactly with the exception of not adding the wine because I didn't have any. Plus I used dried chives and parsley because that's all I had in the house.
I had this last night at a little get together and it was a hit! I added bacon and used the bacon fat instead of the butter to saute the onions and potato's. Thanks so much for the recipe!
Very warm and comforting. I halved the cumin and put in 1/2 tsp basil instead of the sage (didn't have any) I also used green onion instead of chives. It came out lovely. I didn't have any seperation problems and simmered it a long time.
Thanks for the tip about it separating! I also waited to add the milk until close to the end. I did add a little more chicken stock (about 1/2 cup more) after the flour to make up for the lack of milk otherwise the liquid would have been too thick. When you do add the milk be sure to first whisk some of the hot liquid into it so you're not adding cold milk to the pot (as that can also cause separation).
This recipe was just ok to me. I feel like the seasonings are a bit off or maybe it's missing something. I'm just not sure what. It's a decent recipe but I think it needs a bit of tweaking.
