158 Ratings
  • 5 Rating Star 86
  • 4 Rating Star 43
  • 3 Rating Star 22
  • 2 Rating Star 6
  • 1 Rating Star 1

I made this simple (but delicious) dish for my boyfriend, and by the end of the meal, I could tell I had graduated to 'prospective mate' status. That was 26 years ago, and I'm still making it for him. This is best served over wide egg noodles.

prep:
20 mins
cook:
2 hrs
total:
2 hrs 20 mins
Servings:
6
Max Servings:
6
Advertisement

Ingredients

Directions

  • In a Dutch oven over medium-high heat, sear beef on all sides. Stir in onion, and saute until golden brown. Add mushrooms, butter, mushroom soup and wine. Reduce heat, cover, and simmer for 2 hours.

    Ads will not print with your recipe

Nutrition Facts

432.32 calories; 31.8 g protein; 8.31 g carbohydrates; 28.22 g fat; 113.49 mg cholesterol; 471.99 mg sodium.Full Nutrition


Reviews (128)

Read All Reviews

Most helpful positive review

CLALONDE
08/07/2007
I made this for my in-laws last night and it was a HUGE HIT!! I made a few changes though: -I used Top Sirloin - the meat was SOOO tender -dredged the beef cubes in s&p seasoned flour -seared with garlic in pan -added fresh thyme marjoram and rosemary -I used a Pinot Noir and added a bit more than the recipe called for for good measure! This turned out beautifully!
(70)

Most helpful critical review

Anonymous
02/18/2009
I did not care for this.
158 Ratings
  • 5 Rating Star 86
  • 4 Rating Star 43
  • 3 Rating Star 22
  • 2 Rating Star 6
  • 1 Rating Star 1
CLALONDE
08/07/2007
I made this for my in-laws last night and it was a HUGE HIT!! I made a few changes though: -I used Top Sirloin - the meat was SOOO tender -dredged the beef cubes in s&p seasoned flour -seared with garlic in pan -added fresh thyme marjoram and rosemary -I used a Pinot Noir and added a bit more than the recipe called for for good measure! This turned out beautifully!
(70)
Linda Hamilton
01/23/2007
Made this for the second time last night and it turns out great. The only changes I made were to add in some crushed garlic while sauteeing the onions using 20 oz. of mushrooms using 1 cup of wine and sprinkling in some pepper at the start of simmering. Plenty of sauce and thickening with the water/cornstarch slurry is no problem. We served over egg noodles and mixed in some green peas too. The leftover beef and sauce is destined for a lovely Shepherd's Pie this weekend. Love this recipe.
(39)
Kristi Goulette Lozensky
07/01/2007
I liked this recipe unlike my husband and daughter they didn't care for it. Which is why I gave this recipe 4 stars. I lightly coated the meat with flour and browned as suggested by other users. I sliced the onions and fresh mushrooms and put into a slow cooker along with the meat soup (I doubled the sauce and used 1 can golden mushroom and 1 can 99% fat free cream of mushroom soup) and 1 cup of wine (I also used the wine to de-glaze the pan I browned the meat in before adding to the slow cooker. Those brown bits add alot of flavor). I also added 2 garlic cloves pressed to the mixture (I love garlic!). I cooked everything in the slow cooker on low for about 4 hours and served over egg noodles and topped with freshly choppped parsley.
(37)
Sarah Jo
02/07/2012
This is a great quick stroganoff. I like to use a cheap cut of meat with this (you CAN use beef or pork stew meat and have it come out fabulously and fake it I do it all the time) and let it simmer in the sauce for an hour. The longer it simmers the more tender the meat gets. Right before serving I like to add a good amount of sour cream and a teaspoon each of dried oregano and dried basil. This doubles well and the leftovers always reheat wonderfully. We like this best over buttered egg noodles. NOTE: Any Campbell's mushroom soup will work in this recipe I like to use the "beefy mushroom" soup if I have it on hand.
(20)
HARRYMARTINII
09/04/2006
Excellent! Made for guests -- easy for dinner party. I followed other suggestions and doubled the soup and wine. Perfect. I also added some thyme and served over egg noodles with chopped parsley as a garnish. Great flavor and easy. Would transfer easily to a slow cooker recipe. By the way it will look very thick when you first mix it all t ogether. Do not worry the sauce will thin as it simmers. No need to add additional liquid with 2 cans of soup and a cup of wine. Oh I also added a tsp of minced garlic to the oil in which the meat was seared as others suggested. This one is a defnite keeper.
(19)
FRED NIELSON
06/08/2003
A delicious recipe! Don't worry if you can't find a burgundy for your dish cabernet sauvignon or merlots work nicely and also serve nicely as your table wine for the evening. Serve on rice or pasta with some nice french bread and you are ready. MMM! Ambrosia!
(15)
Lisa Dunlap
01/04/2011
This is delicious! Regular cream of mushroom soup works very well if you can't find golden mushroom. I used baby portabellas and they were delicious as well. I also used 1/2 bottle of Red Truck Pinot Noir and omitted the butter. It does need to simmer for about 2 hours. When you mix everything together the sauce looks very pink but after simmering it is brown. I simmered uncovered after 2 hours to thicken the sauce and served over baked potatoes. This is one of my favorite winter recipes!
(14)
Deanna Gibson
05/26/2004
This is a wonderful recipe. The sauce is just delicious and the prep time is short. I made a few modifications to the recipe. I added an extra can of mushroom soup and an extra splash of wine (I used burgundy cooking wine). It made plenty of sauce. I also omitted the butter (by accident) but it still tasted great! I also baked it at 300 for an hour and a half instead of using a dutch oven. I used horrible tough steaks and they turned out tender and juicy with this recipe. This recipe smelled so good while it was cooking and was perfect served on top of rice. I will definitely be making this recipe again. Thanks for the great recipe!!
(13)
Anonymous
03/11/2006
Delicious. I've made this a few times. Last time I coated the beef in flour before browning. This helped make the meat more tender and also create a thicker sauce
(12)