Wonderful! I have been looking for such a recipe for a very long time -sugar cookies that are soft and stay soft! Yummmmm - they are delicious! The larger size is fun too. I made them to celebrate my daughters 4th birthday at school - I piped icing on ("Really good frosting" from this site). The kids loved them - (they all ate them as opposed to my previous experiences where I took cupcakes and they licked the frosting off and threw the cupcakes away!:- ) I scaled the recipe down to 26 servings and it made 15 large cookies. Thanks!!
This recipe is soooo close to what I have been looking for. Growing up near the michigan indiana border I grew up with amish sugar cookies and can not find a recipe for them now. Could be the same but maybe when I cut the recipe way down I need to do some tweaking to it now. SO soft and sweet (I do remember the recipe calling for brown sugar so I cut sugar in 1/2 and subbed in brown sugar) They leveled off nicely for a drop cookie. I was worried with the first tray because my 3 year old dropped the cookies but they still turned out round and smooth. Great recipe!!!
My family loved them. They especially liked the size. They liked them w/o frosting.
I didn't care for this at all. It tasted like a cross between bread and yellow cake. Was not very sweet at all. After I tried one I didn't even bother baking the next tray of cookies.
Very soft tasty cookie but they spread and thinned out too much. I'd go easy on the milk or add a little more flour next time.
This is a cake style cookie. I'm giving it 4 stars because personally I don't care as much for the cake style cookies but in their class they are pretty good. They are cheap easy and use sour milk all good reasons I'll probably make them again. I keep a list of recipes that use sour milk for the inevitable occurrence of milk going sour on me. Never throw it out!
Since I hate chilling and rolling out dough I was delighted to find a drop cookie recipe that is very tasty easy to make and bake. Love the soft and chewy texture. Thanks!
I just made these this afternoon and my husband said they are the best batch I've made to date. I love the soft cake style...they are great even without frosting!
