2-24-2016 ~I never have plain yogurt around, Greek or otherwise, so I made this completely with sour cream. Other than that I prepared this right down the list of ingredients, exactly as written. I was encouraged at each addition, liking every ingredient in the mix. And then I tasted it... and was unimpressed. It tasted like a doctored up common burger sauce or Thousand Island dressing masquerading as a "Southwest" dressing, the sweetness of the ketchup very apparent and disagreeable. Moments after I tasted it I was already planning my review, indicating this sweetness and what I might do differently, perhaps using tomato sauce or tomato paste rather than ketchup to combat the sweetness and/or adding a little hot sauce. But by the time I used it on my salad (lettuce, slow cooked shredded chicken, sliced avocado, tomatoes, green onion, black olives and shredded Mexican-blend cheese), magic had happened! The flavors had indeed mellowed out and combined, resulting in a complex but balanced dressing with the initial sweetness gone. It was not only much improved, it was just right. In fact, this was spot on, and I just can't see messing around with it at all. DO include everything, including the cilantro, which gave this freshness and a tease of its flavor. The dressing just wouldn't be the same (meaning as GOOD) without it.
I often wonder how something so simple can taste so incredibly good. I tasted this as a dip and quickly decided that we are having taco salads for dinner tonight with this as a dressing. This would go well on bugers chops or anything else you can think of.
I came on-line to look for a Southwestern Style Salad Dressing. This worked out very well. After storing in the refrigerator for the flavors to meld I may find a dash of hot sauce in order but this is very good dressing!
This dressing was very good and super easy to make. I did add more garlic and some additional spices to kick it up a notch. The best advice I can say is let it sit in the frig for a good 24 hours.
It was good. The cilantro was unnecessary to me in my opinion. This was a quick easy and healthy dressing to make.
This was easy to make with ingredients I had in house. I don't like cilantro so I skipped it. I'll definitely make this again.
This is a simple Delicious recipe. I made it for a Fajita salad. Very refreshing on a 100 degree day. Thanks
The whole family LOVED this! Easy and very tasty- even better after sitting for several hours. Was out of sour cream so used all yogurt. Nice and tangy- mmmmmmmmmmm!
Phenomenal sauce I didn't use yogurt but all sour cream and I added a bit of Cajun seasoning to it.
I'm definitely in the minority here but I thought this was just OK and I let it sit a whole day before using. I thought it was a bit too thick as a dressing. The sweetness of the ketchup was more than I expected. Also I felt it needed more cilantro and something else--maybe some hot sauce or cayenne pepper. It was OK on my chicken taco salad but I kept thinking a little ranch dressing might make the salad tastier. Thanks anyway.
