Before I even asked him for his opinion, Hubs voluntarily remarked, "These are the best chocolate chip cookies I ever ate." What?! I wasn't EVEN prepared for that! Do you know how many different kinds of chocolate chip cookies I've made over the years? Not to mention my standby favorite? Subsequent "m'mmms" and "yummy" reinforced that review. Now in all fairness, when I first told him I was considering making chocolate chip cookies with whiskey in them, he was all over that! Oh yeah, whiskey in cookies! When I tasted them I thought ok, you're going to be disappointed because you can't even taste any whiskey in them (Hubs insists you do, "a little bit"). He and I tend to differ in what we consider a good chocolate chip cookie (I like mine sort of dry and crunchy) so we'll use his 5-star review: He says he doesn't know why, it's difficult to describe - his brain and his taste buds just tell him these are the best. The whiskey, he said four cookies later, somehow balances out the sweetness and makes them interesting. I'm happy to be the first to review these Nashville Nosher, and Hubs thanks you for the best chocolate chip cookie he ever ate.
I recommend: 1) if using salted butter don't add the tsp of salt to the batter; 2) only use 1/2 cup granulated sugar; 3) use 3 Tbsp whiskey; and 4) sprinkle salt on the cookie balls before baking. I made the recipe (with the changes above )this weekend and was really impressed! When mixed the batter is extremely wet for cookie dough. I did NOT add any additional flour and just dropped globs of the dough onto the cookie sheet. I was thinking that these would bake and run all over the tray but they ended up forming nicely and actually had a lot more 'body' than any other chocolate chip cookie recipe I've made so far! The whiskey adds so much depth and flavor to the recipe and the salt just finishes it off nicely. This is by far a favorite of mine and the extra whiskey is worth it!! Great recipe!!
We made these cookies with jack Daniels honey whiskey as it was the only one I had on hand. The only other differences is I increased the whiskey by 3 TBS. they were amazing! This is now my go to for. Chocolate chip cookies! The honey whiskey did make them a tad bit sweeter but still very yummy!!
DELICIOUS...I used 3 cups flour..my dough was rather thin..and my cookies are WONDERFUL!!!!
Didn't have to change a thing! Delicious
Delicious!!! Based on a couples reviews I added just a little extra flour. And I added chopped pecans & 2 tbs whiskey. These turned out great. Crisp on the outside soft & moist inside. Everyone loved them. The whiskey flavor isn't super strong but adds a richness to the cookie. I'll definitely be baking these again!!!
Best cookie recipe ever! Needed to add an extra 1/2 cup flour but otherwise they were perfect. I will probably omit the whiskey and make this my go-to cookie recipe for kids lunches.
I have tried numerous chocolate chip cookie recipes and this recipe is the best by far. I took other reviewers suggestions and added more whiskey - 1 1/2 tablespoon for 1/2 batch or 3 tablespoons for a full batch. This was the only change to the recipe I made. The whiskey seems to intensify the flavors in the cookie.
This was a nice spin on regular chocolate chip cookies. I turned them into Kentucky cookies instead of Tennessee since I used the Jim Beam that I had on hand. Based on the site reviews I used a very generous tablespoon of whiskey and may be even more liberal next time. I thought there was too much salt in these however so I will cut back to 1/2 tsp next time. I left the flour as is and they were perfect.
