It's no wonder I liked this! With the exception of the white wine which I really liked this is the way I've been making Beef Stroganoff since I was a young girl in the early 60s from a paperback Sealtest cookbook! (Any of you out there old enough to remember Sealtest Dairy?) Two minor criticisms however. First it is counterintuitive to cook a pretty decent cut of meat like sirloin for "two to three hours." "Back in the day " when I was making this with round steak it was indeed necessary to simmer (braise) the meat in beef broth for an hour and a half or so to ensure tenderness. But with sirloin once browned it didn't need much longer on the stove than it took to pull it all together with the remaining ingredients - ten minutes tops. Second the wine should be used to deglaze the pan once the meat is browned not just before serving as the recipe instructs. You want the alcohol to cook off. These in my view are two important considerations for the success of this dish. Also while I did not measure any ingredients precisely I do know I used more broth and less flour than the recipe directs. Finally don't forget to include pepper with the salt! I served this with hot buttered egg noodles tossed with fresh chives and a sprinkle of fresh chopped parsley for garnish.
I'm on a budget so instead of beef sirloin I used beef STEW MEAT. I made sure that the recipe simmered for a while before I used the stew meat as the simmering helps tenderize the tougher cuts of meat. When I floured the meat I added just a little onion powder garlic powder and fresh ground pepper. I made no other changes. Mine was done simmering at just under two hours. I served this over hot buttered egg noodles. My family INHALED this. Out of the whole skillet there was a small amount for my husband to take for work the next day. Delicious!
This is absolutely delicious. I made this exactly as directed and got a dish that was creamy rich with flavor and hearty. My son liked it a lot and he is not a beef fan. I only had ground beef on hand but it worked just fine following the same directions. I sprinkled the flour & salt mixture over the ground beef before placing it in the pan. It adds flavor and thickens the drippings. Thank you for adding this!
Very delicious and easy to follow instructions! This was my first time making Beef Stroganoff; I came to allrecipes.com looking for something my friend described as having made and I chose this one because it uses the same ingredients. As I was nervous about the meat tenderizing I used a tenderloin roast which cut simmer time to almost nothing. Simple made mostly with ingredients commonly on hand with an outstanding result! Creamy beefy mushrooms. You won't go wrong!
This was one of the best stroganoff recipes I've ever tried. I just shared some leftovers with a coworker and she agreed. I did add some balsamic vinegar to the stock mixture and I added more than the called for beef stock as the roux was too thick without it. Very very tasty!
Hubby loves Beef Stroganoff so I've been making it for him for many years always trying a different recipe. Finally this is the keeper for beef stroganoff!! Yeaaaaa. Really awesome flavor. I served over orzo and cut the recipe in half so I eyed a lot of the amounts and it still turned out yumeee!! tRY IT you won't be dissapointed. Thanks to Nana.
Delish! And yes I made this in the crockpot.....used some marsala wine since I had no white wine and at the end of slow cooking for about 9-10 hours added 4 oz. of low fat cream cheese and 1c of low fat sour cream thick creamy and delicious! Served over buttered egg noodles family loved...thanks!
Great recipe. I recommend de-glazing the pan with the white wine and increasing the amount of beef stock.Any cut of beef can be used increase cooking times for 'tougher' cuts. Philly cheese is a great substitute for sour cream. Serve with fresh parsley and egg noodles. I have made this recipe many times its a firm family favorite
Fantastic! I thought I had beef broth but was out so I used Au Jus. The best Stroganoff I have ever made!
