- of Reviews
Reviews:
Most Helpful
UGC Reviews Modal
Reviews for: Photos of Banana Flips
Reviews:
Most Helpful
1 of 36
Very good - a hit with the kids and all at the potluck and quick to make. If you use powdered sugar as the other reviews mention the substitution ratio given on this site is 1 3/4 c. pwdr sugar = 1 c. granulated sugar. I used granulated and had no problems but you have to beat & beat & beat the sugar/butter/shortening for a VERY long time until the sugar dissolves or you will have gritty filling. Maybe not the job for a hand held mixer!
Helpful
(50)
OMG this tastes exactly like the banana flips you buy in the store. I didn't have a yellow cake mix so used a banana cake mix & a little extra banana extract. The banana cake mix really brings out the banana flavor. And even better the next day. I will be making this again.
Helpful
(26)
The filling is a good base recipe but it's better with confectioner's sugar (in equal amt) instead of granulated.
Helpful
(20)
The cake was great. However using the granulated sugar in the frosting was not as great. I recommend using powdered sugar.
Helpful
(13)
Great cake! I do agree with the other reviews though. Powered sugar should be used instead of granulated in the filling for a smoother texture. Thanks for sharing this recipe!!
Helpful
(11)
How to review this masterpiece? Hmmmm....Well FIRST it's a 10 star recipe! I have made this twice now WITH the advice of using powdered sugar instead of granular. AND....I had an old banana and added that to the cake for kicks & giggles (will ALWAYS do that!). Now for the "filling"...I could NOT find any banana extract on the day I was to make this SO I purchased some Loran's Banana Cream Oil...yes the kind used for candy making...BUT you CAN add it to other things as well. I put in a DROP at a time just until I got a very "light" banana flavor and was I glad I did...it balanced out the MEGA MOIST banana cake with the not so "sweet" filling. Am I gushing?:-) It's a GREAT recipe and something different to do with an old banana or two! THANKS FOR POSTING THIS...really!
Helpful
(11)
This turned out awesome. It tasted just like the banana flips you could buy years ago....I used granulated sugar in the filling, next time I will beat longer or use powdered sugar as suggested. I might also try to add a banana to the cake batter, but it tasted great without needing to make any changes. My picky young eaters LOVED it !! :)
Helpful
(8)
I just made this and it is great. I added a banana to the cake mix and used 2 sticks of real butter and 1 stick of parkay for the filling. what the recipe doesn't tell you is that you have to beat the filling for a good 10 minutes until the sugar is no longer granually. will make again
Helpful
(7)
after 17 minutes in the oven the cakes were still very battery. i had to go to the store so i told my husband to check it in 15 minutes. it was a little over baked but it gave a nice crisp on the sides. i was a little hesitant to make the filling... especially because it called for flour and there's no cooking it but it turned out really great. i didn't add all the milk i just kinda stopped on the consistency i preferred. it was really thick and separated the layers of the cake nicely. for something optional i heated chocolate fudge and caramel as drizzles for my guests. they enjoyed it... even the ones that were very conscious about their weight and sugar intake. they all had a second serving.
Helpful
(5)