Flavorful pie named after key limes, found in the Florida Keys. Garnish each slice with whipped cream if you like.

Recipe Summary

Servings:
8
Yield:
1 pie
Advertisement

Ingredients

8
Original recipe yields 8 servings
The ingredient list now reflects the servings specified
Ingredient Checklist

Directions

Instructions Checklist
  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C).

    Advertisement
  • In a medium mixing bowl, combine eggs, condensed milk, lime juice, and lime rind. Beat on medium speed with electric mixer for about 1 minute or until mixture is thoroughly blended. Pour into baked pastry shell.

  • Bake in preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, until center is set. Cool on a rack for 15 minutes, then chill at least 2 hours before serving. Garnish with whipped cream if desired. Immediately refrigerate any leftovers. Do not store for longer than 3 days.

Nutrition Facts

269 calories; protein 7g 14% DV; carbohydrates 36g 12% DV; fat 11.3g 17% DV; cholesterol 86.4mg 29% DV; sodium 190.7mg 8% DV. Full Nutrition
Advertisement

Reviews (46)

Read More Reviews

Most helpful positive review

Rating: 5 stars
05/04/2011
This is the same recipe that Cook's Illustrated uses. For those of you finding it "grainy", MAKE SURE to blend the lime juice with the condensed milk very well BEFORE you add the eggs. Adding the lime juice directly to the eggs in any way will start to "cook" the eggs from so much acid all at once. This happened to me when I was in a rush one time and just dumped the eggs, condensed milk, and lime juice all at once. Read More
(102)

Most helpful critical review

Rating: 3 stars
04/06/2006
In my honest opinion - the recipe deserves 5 stars for it's simplicty and the the fact that it can be made so quickly... but for taste and texture it's an average 3 star rating. It's just the right amount of tartness using 1/2 cup but if you're looking for a more intense lime taste you can you might try using 3/4 cup instead. I used fresh key limes (if you don't have a garlic press to juice the limes the next best way to juice them would be to cut them in half and score the halves - take a teaspoon and insert it into the scored half and twist the teaspoon as you squeeze the lime - this helps ensure you get all the juice possible) - just run the juice through a fine mesh drainer to remove seeds and any pulp. As one reviewer mentioned the texture is a little bit grainy- most people wouldn't notice it hence another reviewer disagreeing and noting it was smooth and creamy. I could tell it slightly off in the texture but it doesn't affect the flavor. I used a graham cracker crust (store bought because I was all out of graham crackers)... I prefer a graham cracker crust versus a regular pie crust for this particular pie. However if you do use a graham cracker crust the upper part of the crust will overcook due to the length of time and temperature the pie must cook for. Read More
(40)
52 Ratings
  • 5 star values: 35
  • 4 star values: 11
  • 3 star values: 3
  • 2 star values: 3
  • 1 star values: 0
Rating: 5 stars
05/04/2011
This is the same recipe that Cook's Illustrated uses. For those of you finding it "grainy", MAKE SURE to blend the lime juice with the condensed milk very well BEFORE you add the eggs. Adding the lime juice directly to the eggs in any way will start to "cook" the eggs from so much acid all at once. This happened to me when I was in a rush one time and just dumped the eggs, condensed milk, and lime juice all at once. Read More
(102)
Rating: 3 stars
04/06/2006
In my honest opinion - the recipe deserves 5 stars for it's simplicty and the the fact that it can be made so quickly... but for taste and texture it's an average 3 star rating. It's just the right amount of tartness using 1/2 cup but if you're looking for a more intense lime taste you can you might try using 3/4 cup instead. I used fresh key limes (if you don't have a garlic press to juice the limes the next best way to juice them would be to cut them in half and score the halves - take a teaspoon and insert it into the scored half and twist the teaspoon as you squeeze the lime - this helps ensure you get all the juice possible) - just run the juice through a fine mesh drainer to remove seeds and any pulp. As one reviewer mentioned the texture is a little bit grainy- most people wouldn't notice it hence another reviewer disagreeing and noting it was smooth and creamy. I could tell it slightly off in the texture but it doesn't affect the flavor. I used a graham cracker crust (store bought because I was all out of graham crackers)... I prefer a graham cracker crust versus a regular pie crust for this particular pie. However if you do use a graham cracker crust the upper part of the crust will overcook due to the length of time and temperature the pie must cook for. Read More
(40)
Rating: 4 stars
10/20/2011
I made this pie with my oldest son. We made a homemade graham cracker crust other than that we made no other changes. This turned out pretty good but I think that I like key lime pies made with egg yolks instead of the whole egg. I think the mouth feel is different it's creamier. There's nothing wrong with this recipe it's a personal preferance. The kids and I liked it though. I served it with whipped cream on top. As with most key lime pies this pie tastes better the longer it sits. Read More
(23)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
07/09/2003
Having tried Key Lime Pie for the first time in Florida recently I guess you could say I am hooked. I thought I would try to make it for Easter dessert for a change of pace. I am glad I did. This pie was EXTREMELY YUMMY! Definitely a keeper. Thanks Carolyn! Read More
(15)
Rating: 3 stars
11/05/2003
I had great hopes for this recipe after reading the reviews and seeing how simple it was to prepare. Alas the texture was not to our liking. It kind of reminded me of a grainy cheesecake. I'm in search of a creamy light key lime pie and this wasn't it. Read More
(14)
Rating: 4 stars
02/02/2008
This is the "standard" key lime pie recipe from the back of the juice bottle. It is easy and excellent and I've made it many many times! Last night I went to the store and bought my pie crust condensed milk and juice...came home pre-heated the oven and opened the fridge only to discover that I only had 1 egg. I was disappointed and wasn't about to got BACK to the store. I almost gave up but discovered a package of low-fat cream cheese and decided to wing it. I combined the can of condensed milk a little more than 1/2 cup of juice 1 egg and half the packet of cream cheese...and it worked! It's a much more creamy pie but very tasty too...so if you're ever in a egg pinch or prefer a more creamy pie this might be one solution for you. (p.s. You have to let it cool completely before it sets.) Read More
(12)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
03/23/2003
Delicious! I made this last weekend while my sister-in-law visited. She said that it was a very good key lime pie (I had never had it before). The texture was good--I did use my new microplane grater for the lime rind. I found it VERY tart (as I am told key lime pies are supposed to be) so I made a slightly sweetened sour cream topping and offered sliced macerated strawberries for options. Surprisingly wonderful given the small amount of effort required. Thanks so much for sharing! Read More
(11)
Rating: 5 stars
09/03/2005
A most refreshing dessert. My daughter first made this with regular lime juice, the next time we used key lime juice, either way, it is great. A wonderful summer dessert recipe. Thanks! Read More
(11)
Rating: 5 stars
12/22/2006
Nice recipe. Would make it again. I used a cracker base, but not Graham crackers as they are loaded with bad stuff. I used Paul Newman's Arrowroot crackers. I am at a loss to understand the comments that say the texture is grainy. Eggs, milk, limes hardly add up to grainy. Gettting the juice from the lime is as easy as putting the lime in the microwave for a 15 seconds and slicing it open and squeeze. I second the lady that uses the microfile. They are wonderful for any grating - limes, lemons, cheese. Worth every penny you pay for them. My Husband gives this key lime pie 9 out of 10 and he is the expert LOL. Happy Christmas to all. Read More
(8)
Advertisement