THIS WOULD HAVE GOT 5 STARS, BUT THE COOKING TIME IS WAY WAY OFF! THE TIME TO SEAR A ONE TO ONE AND 1/2 INCH STEAK IS ABOUT 1 MINUTE ON EACH SIDE. ANY LONGER AND YOU MIGHT AS WELL USE A CAN OF STARKIST AND CALL IT A DAY...THE SAUCE HOWEVER IS A KEEPER!
Delicious! And smelled so good while making it. I agree with all the other comments that 5 minutes is way too long for searing the tuna. 1-2 minutes per side is more like it. The tuna got cold while making the sauce unfortunately but a quick trip to the microwave before pouring the sauce on fixed that. Squeezed a couple of blood oranges but not enough for 2 cups so I mixed it with regular orange juice. Again turned out delicious!
This was wonderful! Our family had never tried Ahi Tuna so this was a great 1st taste. I didn't have a blood orange so I used mango puree...tasty!
My boyfriend and I were looking for some good fish recipes and stumbled on to this one. IT WAS FANTASTIC!! The sauce was absalutely delicious! My boyfriend loved the tuna seared for the time called for. I on the other hand did 3 on one side and 2 on the other. Came out great! We definately will make this again!
This was a really good recipe. I was looking for something to eat with a good light crisp champagne and this was it. The tuna was wonderful although I lightly salted and peppered the steaks then seared in olive oil. I could not find blood oranges (Limited Selection at military commissary) so I used orange juice with a little bit of lime and lemon juice and some sugar along with the white wine and a pat of butter with chopped shallot and garlic. It was a little sour but that Im sure is just becaus of the lemon/lime. When I find the blood oranges or juice I will try again because it sounds so delisicous. And in contradiction to the last review I seared the tuna for about 3 - 4 minutes on one side and 2 - 3 on the other. IT wasnt flaky at all just delicious.
I served this dish for Valentine's day dinner. Searing time for each side was up to 2 minutes for a delicious rare center. However the blood orange sauce was too tart for our taste and didn't seem to complement rare ahi.
Pretty good! Simple. A few comments: seared for 1.5 min first side 1 min second side and it was almost too much. 1 tbsp of butter in the ingredients is not used in the directions. Needed a little salt but that's personal. Used a little regular orange juice instead of 2 cups blood orange juice touch of sweetness was great. Nice recipe!
My ahi tuna steaks were almost an inch thick and I seared them about 4 minutes per side and they were cooked just right. I started the sauce in a separate pan using a cup of fresh juice from Cuties mandarins - then added the mixture to the fish saucepan when the steaks were done - to save time. The sauce was excellent and I'd use it again on cod or halibut.
Agreed with other reviewers- a quick sear in a hot cast iron pan should be no longer than a minute or so per side for the fish. I subbed in mirin for the white wine and regular fresh squeezed orange for the blood orange juice. Layered sliced tuna over a green salad with crumbled blue cheese and edamame and drizzled the sauce on top- worked out wonderfully!
