This old-fashioned pie is wonderful to freeze and to have on hand for unexpected guests!

Advertisement

Ingredients

8
Original recipe yields 8 servings
The ingredient list now reflects the servings specified
Ingredient Checklist

Directions

Instructions Checklist
  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees (175 degrees C).

    Advertisement
  • Beat eggs until frothy; add butter, sugar and flour. Beat until smooth.

  • Stir in buttermilk, vanilla, lemon juice and nutmeg; pour into pie shell.

  • Bake for 40 to 60 minutes, or until center is firm.

Partner Tip

Reynolds® Aluminum foil can be used to keep food moist, cook it evenly, and make clean-up easier.

Nutrition Facts

413 calories; 21.2 g total fat; 101 mg cholesterol; 257 mg sodium. 51.9 g carbohydrates; 5.2 g protein; Full Nutrition

Reviews (325)

Read More Reviews

Most helpful positive review

Rating: 5 stars
09/09/2006
My new favorite! I have made it twice. The first time the crust almost burned before inside done- so the second time I microwaved the inside in a glass bowl for 2minutes to speed up the cooking time inside. I also cooked the pie crust in the oven- I love my crust flakey on the bottom- After the pie crust was lightly cooked I poured the microwaved pie mixture in the pie and cooked till the crust was a nice brown and the inside was done. Awesome! I speed up many recipes using the microwave to precook the insides alittle faster. Pies or casseroles or baked potatoes! Read More
(463)

Most helpful critical review

Rating: 3 stars
03/15/2012
First attempt at this and it was good but a little too sweet for my tastes. Being diabetic I used splenda instead of sugar possibly that was it. Read More
(7)
409 Ratings
  • 5 star values: 289
  • 4 star values: 80
  • 3 star values: 27
  • 2 star values: 8
  • 1 star values: 5
Rating: 5 stars
09/09/2006
My new favorite! I have made it twice. The first time the crust almost burned before inside done- so the second time I microwaved the inside in a glass bowl for 2minutes to speed up the cooking time inside. I also cooked the pie crust in the oven- I love my crust flakey on the bottom- After the pie crust was lightly cooked I poured the microwaved pie mixture in the pie and cooked till the crust was a nice brown and the inside was done. Awesome! I speed up many recipes using the microwave to precook the insides alittle faster. Pies or casseroles or baked potatoes! Read More
(463)
Rating: 5 stars
09/09/2006
My new favorite! I have made it twice. The first time the crust almost burned before inside done- so the second time I microwaved the inside in a glass bowl for 2minutes to speed up the cooking time inside. I also cooked the pie crust in the oven- I love my crust flakey on the bottom- After the pie crust was lightly cooked I poured the microwaved pie mixture in the pie and cooked till the crust was a nice brown and the inside was done. Awesome! I speed up many recipes using the microwave to precook the insides alittle faster. Pies or casseroles or baked potatoes! Read More
(463)
Rating: 5 stars
11/26/2013
I think, people should give review off of the recipe that is posted, not a recipe that they have created by changing what has been kindly given to us. Post your own, if you are just going to change everything, and then say I tweaked this, added that, and omitted this, other than that, was a great recipe. It frustrates me. This is a great pie, just the way it is, thank you for sharing. Read More
(445)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
09/20/2004
My family loved this recipe. I made two pies and one I used nutmeg and the other ground cinnamon. I have to say the one with cinnamon came out better. A word of advice, use deep dish pie crust.Thanks For Such A Wonderful Recipe. Read More
(268)
Rating: 4 stars
07/06/2010
This recipe will do but I have one that's been used in my family for generations that notes some differences: 3 eggs (beaten) 1 1/2 C. sugar 1/2 cup (1 stick) butter (melted cooled to lukewarm) 1/2 C. Buttermilk (make your own by adding a tabls. of vinegar to milk and let sit 1/2 hour - same chemical reaction) 2 Tabls. flour rounded - not heaping 1 teas. pure vanilla. Mix/sift together (sifting originated decades ago when flour almost always had mealy bugs in it!!) sugar and flour add buttermilk butter eggs and vanilla. Mix well. Pour into pie shell (hard for the best cook to beat Pillsbury's frig crust - but use a Deep Dish if using frozen). Bake at 400 for 15 minutes. Reduce to 325 for apx. 30-40 minutes. Note: Pie should rise up in the middle - it will fall to level upon cooking. Additional test; shake - should not wiggle in the middle. This pie melts in your mouth and couldn't be easier. Variations: Add some fresh sliced peaches in a round across the top when in season. Or - Toss over some mini chocolate chips after that first 15 minutes. Enjoy whatever version!! Read More
(176)
Rating: 5 stars
06/03/2008
I made this pie today and it really turned out great. I did a little bit of substitution--instead of eggs I used egg beaters, Splenda instead of sugar and Reduced Fat Buttermilk. Not sure how many calories I saved but it was still great and it was also more diabetic friendly. Read More
(155)
Advertisement
Rating: 5 stars
03/19/2010
LOVE LOVE LOVE! We generally purchase a buttermilk pie each week from an amazing restaurant ( 28 per pie) that we truly love...until we decided to try THIS recipe:o) I have already made two pies and they literally disappeared. The flavor and texture are right on. I do not add the entire tbs of lemon juice (but almost)...and I increase the vanilla by just a smidge...besides that - NO changes and you end up with total perfection! THANKS SO MUCH for the recipe:o) Read More
(85)
Rating: 5 stars
11/01/2003
I've been searcing for the recipe my grandmother used to make and this is very close. Tasted great and was easy to make. Boyfriend loved it! Read More
(46)
Rating: 5 stars
12/13/2005
OH MY! Yummy pie! I used 2 of the shallow pie shells & baked about 25 minutes. What a perfect recipe. Everyone should try this- don't change a thing! Thanks so much for sharing! Read More
(40)
Rating: 4 stars
08/17/2010
I made this for the first time (yesterday) for an office party, which everyone raved over. Very simple and easy. One suggestion: for a more intense lemon flavor; I used fresh lemon juice from a whole lemon (a smidge over 2 Tbsp) and zested some of the rind into the batter. Also, bake on the lowest rack in the oven. I did this, which allowed it to baked completely through the center, yet to a golden brown perfection. - Then, dust it lightly with powdered sugar. Read More
(37)
Rating: 3 stars
03/15/2012
First attempt at this and it was good but a little too sweet for my tastes. Being diabetic I used splenda instead of sugar possibly that was it. Read More
(7)