These Are the 6 Best Turkey Fryers You Can Buy, According To Reviews
But never fear, here you'll learn all you need to know when choosing a turkey fryer, including information on propane vs. electric fryers, indoor vs. outdoor frying, and what size fryer to go for. After scouring the internet and its countless reviews, I've whittled it down to the best of the best. Here are the six best turkey fryers, according to the most trusted source: Online reviewers.
Best Turkey Fryers at a Glance:
- Best Overall Turkey Fryer: Bayou Classic 1118 Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer with GasOne 200 Small Burnerhouse
- Best Value Turkey Fryer: Backyard Pro Deluxe Aluminum Turkey Fryer Kit
- Best Indoor Turkey Fryer: Masterbuilt Butterball Stainless Steel Electric Indoor Turkey Fryer
- Best Multi-Use Turkey Fryer: Cuisinart Extra-Large Rotisserie Deep Fryer
- Best Oil-Less Turkey Fryer: Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU Infrared Oil-Less Turkey Fryer
- Best Extra-Large Turkey Fryer: Bayou Classic 44-Quart "Big Bird" Kit
What to Consider When Buying a Turkey Fryer
Indoor vs. Outdoor Frying
When deep frying a turkey goes wrong...it goes really wrong. We've all seen the fail videos. Fires are a real possibility when working with turkey fryers, so be sure to refer to our guide on how to deep-fry a turkey for more safety tips.
All that being said, you can deep fry a turkey indoors - IF you use the proper fryer. While most turkey fryers are going to be recommended for outdoor use only (and by outdoor we DON'T mean the deck or the garage), you can still deep fry a turkey if you don't have outdoor space, like in an apartment or condo.
For consumers that don't have the ability to fry outdoors, countertop (i.e. electric) turkey fryers are going to be the safest option, and they can still give a good result. Plus, they don't require a propane tank. For these reasons, we're including both indoor and outdoor fryers in this review.
Propane vs. Electric vs. Oil-Less
There are three common types of turkey fryers: Propane, electric, and oil-less. Propane is probably what you envision when you think of outdoor turkey frying. Similar to an outdoor grill, a propane turkey fryer has a hose that connects to a propane tank, which ignites the propane burner. The burner heats the oil in a large stock pot, which is used to fry the turkey. Propane turkey fryers can only be used outdoors. Don't use them on a deck, in a garage, or on a sloped driveway.
Electric turkey fryers can be used indoors, and tend to be a safer option than propane fryers. There's no open flame or scalding hot oil here! Similar to deep fryers, electric turkey fryers use an adjustable heating element to heat up oil and cook your turkey. One major pro of using an electric fryer is that they feature a thermostat control so you can keep a steady temperature. Plus, they often have an auto shut-off feature for when the oil overheats. But because they require an electrical outlet, electric turkey fryers aren't ideal for portable use.
And finally, oil-less fryers work similarly to propane fryers, just without the oil. They're kind of like giant air fryers, as they circulate hot air to cook and crisp the turkey. This is the perfect pick for the health-conscious consumer. Oil-less fryers do require a propane tank to ignite. Like propane fryers, you should reserve oil-less fryers for outdoor use only.
BTUs, or British thermal unit, refers to the amount of heat that is required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by 1 degree F. In essence, the higher the BTU, the more powerful the fryer, and the less time it will take for the oil to come to temperature. Different fryers are going to have different BTUs, so keep this in mind while shopping for one.
If this isn't your first time cooking a turkey, you know that their size can vary greatly. In order for a turkey to cook evenly, it will need to be fully submerged in oil. This means you'll need to have a turkey fryer that can accommodate the size of your turkey plus the amount of oil needed to cover it. While fryers come in all different sizes, outdoor fryers are generally larger than indoor ones.
Best Turkey Fryers to Buy in 2020
Best Overall: Bayou Classic 1118 Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer with GasOne 200 Small Burnerhouse
To kick off our list, we have two of the most highly rated turkey frying products on the market. Bayou Classic is one of the most reputable brands when it comes to outdoor cooking - selling everything from turkey fryers to seafood boiling equipment. This 32-quart stainless steel stockpot can be used for both!
In addition to the stainless steel stock pot, (which can fry a whole 18-pound turkey), this set also includes a perforated basket, lid, hook. hook plate, three skewers, injector, and a thermometer.
"Deep frying a turkey has been on my bucket list for a long time. This year I took the plunge. After checking what was available at the big box stores, I checked out Amazon. I opted for this stainless steel model for the durability as compared to similar setups with aluminum pots. Stainless steel is inherently more durable than aluminum and by far easier to clean. The kit includes everything but the burner, including the thermometer," says one five-star reviewer.
As the above review states, you'll need a propane burner to complete this set. Good news - this 200,000-BTU burner from GasOne has over 1,000 five-star reviews on Amazon: "It took only 15 minutes for my oil to get up to 400-degrees," says one reviewer. Pair these two items together and you'll be more than set for turkey day.
Best Value: Backyard Pro Deluxe Aluminum Turkey Fryer Kit
For a truly all-in-one turkey fryer kit, this set from Backyard Pro is priced at just over $100.
One enthusiastic reviewer says, "Used this to try a Christmas turkey...exceptional! Ordered a deep fryer cookbook, and this will be used quite often, with the extra fryer/steamer attachments, we plan to deep fry a lot. Next target is boneless ribeye roast for Easter."
The light-weight aluminum, though less durable than stainless steel, makes for easy transport. This set comes complete with a burner, a thermometer, multiple perforated baskets, three skewers, and injector, a hook, and a hook plate.
Buy It: $112; Amazon
Best Indoor: Masterbuilt Butterball Stainless Steel Electric Indoor Turkey Fryer
Looking for a safe, mess-free, way to cook a turkey indoors? The Masterbuilt Butterball electric fryer has been the standard in electric turkey frying for years. It works similarly to a deep fryer, by lowering the turkey into the hot oil with the use of a chrome-wire basket. Plus, the removable components are dishwasher safe!
"There is no way you can ruin a turkey using this. It's easy to use and doesn't make any mess and the turkey tastes great," says one reviewer.
Another reviewer made the switch from propane to electric, and did not regret it: "I was skeptical about an electric unit being able to keep the oil hot like my propane unit does, but the sheer terror I go through every time I cook, wondering if this is going to be the time this thing is going to blow up, made me have to try it. Long story short, turkey came out great. A 18-pound turkey in 65 minutes cooked to 167 degrees."
Buy It: $99; QVC
Best Multi-Use: Cuisinart Extra-Large Rotisserie Deep Fryer
For a turkey fryer you'll actually want to put to use more than once a year - you can't go wrong with this rotisserie deep fryer from Cuisinart. You can put an entire 14-pound turkey in this puppy. Plus, this comes with an additional frying basket so you can fry or steam all your favorite sides.
This fryer works with or without oil, so you can feel better about using it the rest of the year. And like the Butterball fryer, the removable parts are dishwasher safe for easy cleanup.
"The chicken came out gold and brown and crispy and not greasy. The temperature got where it needed to be and showed us when it was ready and stayed hot throughout. " says one satisfied reviewer.
Buy It: $250; Amazon
Best Oil-Less: Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU Infrared Oil-Less Turkey Fryer
Want that crispy coating without all the oil? This oil-less fryer from Char-Broil uses infrared technology to prepare turkeys up to 16 pounds, no oil necessary. This set comes complete with the cooking basket, lifter, meat thermometer, and quick start cooking guide. However, you will need a propane tank to operate it.
Just be careful, you may get stuck with turkey duty forever after frying your turkey this way: "Cooked a 16-pound turkey for an early Thanksgiving meal. My brother-in-law smoked his. Mine was hands down more juicy and moist. Now I'm stuck doing this every year. But it's easy," says a five-star reviewer.
Buy It: $176; Amazon
Best Extra-Large: Bayou Classic 44-Quart "Big Bird" Kit
If you're looking for a fryer that can handle any turkey, look no further than this 44-qt "Big Bird" fryer from Bayou Classic. This behemoth can handle an excess of 25 pounds of turkey.
This kit is complete with a stainless-steel turkey fryer pot, vented lid, aluminum perforated poultry rack and grab hook, thermometer, stainless-steel seasoning injector, and insulated glove. Thanks to the durable, stainless-steel pot, this is one turkey fryer that will stand the test of time.
"Fried my first turkey last Thanksgiving--this setup worked absolutely great!! Best turkey I've ever cooked, my family and guests were effusive in praise," says one five-star reviewer.
Buy It: $263; Amazon