It's Officially Casserole Season — Here Are the 7 Pans You Need
What's more, most casserole dishes are also beautiful enough to go from the oven to the table for a weeknight meal, holiday dinner, or dinner party. And even some casserole dishes can go safely from the oven to the freezer, or the freezer to the oven, so you can bake ahead for busy nights.
Whether you're adding to your collection of casserole dishes or buying new ones, here are a few things you should consider when picking the best casserole dishes for you:
How do you plan to use it? If you like the idea of baking and freezing casseroles, make sure the casserole dish you buy is made with materials that can withstand the thermal shock. Most ceramic and metal bakers fit this requirement, but not all glass dishes do.
What types of dishes do you cook most? Deep-dish casserole dishes are great for lasagnas and recipes that serve a lot, but not every casserole dish is deep enough for several layers of pasta and sauce. In addition to checking the length and width of a baker, be sure to check the depth so you don't have overflowing dinners.
What investment do you want to make? Many of the best casserole dishes are inexpensive, some less than $25. High-quality casserole dishes from brands like Staub and Emile Henry are more expensive. However, they can be beautiful investments that last you many decades, which more than makes up for their cost across time.
Grab your recipes and your baking plans, and take a look at these seven best casserole dishes worth adding to your kitchen:
- Best Overall: Pyrex Bakeware Rectangular Baking Dish
- Best With Lid: OXO Good Grips Freezer-to-Oven Safe 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish With Lid
- Best Stove-to-Table: Staub 2-Piece Rectangular Baking Dish Set
- Best Petite: Pyrex Littles Toaster Oven Cookware
- Best Non-stick: Rachael Ray Cucina Non-Stick Rectangular Cake Pan
- Best Deep Dish: Emile Henry Modern Classics Rectangular Baker
- Best Round: Staub 14.5-Inch Oval Baking Dish
Best Overall Casserole Dishes to Buy in 2021
Best Overall: Pyrex Bakeware Rectangular Baking Dish
Pyrex is a go-to brand for measuring cups and glass storage containers, so it's no wonder Pyrex casserole dishes are some of the most popular and highly-rated you can buy. The kitchen brand is beloved because they make sturdy, dependable products that are affordable. They are also made to go in the oven, refrigerator, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher. Made in the USA, this casserole dish has a nearly-perfect rating, with reviewers stating they love that it is "[the] perfect size for just about anything." Another reviewer wrote, "I grew up with Pyrex in my mother's kitchen. Still love to cook with Pyrex baking dishes. First quality for low price."
Buy it: $22; Wayfair
Best With Lid: OXO Good Grips Freezer-to-Oven Safe 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish With Lid
This budget-friendly casserole dish has a very useful feature: a lid. The 9-by-13-inch borosilicate glass casserole dish can go from your oven to your freezer and back and withstand the extreme heat changes without worries of cracking or shattering. (Not all glass casserole dishes are shatter-proof.) And if your casserole dish needs to go somewhere else — like a relative's house for the holidays — the BPA-free lid will prevent spills and sloshes. You can even use it to quickly store the leftovers in the fridge (no plastic wrap!).
"Awesome freezer to oven casserole dishes," one Amazon reviewer wrote. "They come with plastic lids. We purchased two 9x13 dishes and they're definitely large enough for a hefty meal for 4+ people. Super easy to clean and store or refrigerate with the lid on. I love these dishes!"
Buy it: $20; Amazon
Best Stove-to-Table: Staub 2-Piece Rectangular Baking Dish Set
These ceramic casserole dishes are not only beautiful for a buffet or dinner table, they're also $25 each, which makes them highly affordable. And coming from a high-quality kitchen brand like Staub, you know these are made to last.
Designed to transfer from the oven to your table, these porcelain-enamel finished dishes can handle up to 575 degrees Fahrenheit, which is safe for a broiler, and they can even go in the freezer without fear of shattering. When in storage, the 7.5" x 6" and 10.5" x 7.5" dishes nest, and because they're on the smaller side, you can use these for dishes with one or two servings or favorite side dishes.
"These bake up gently and clean up easily. Those are the signs of good quality ceramicware. I never really understood the difference until I talked with potters in Canada. They explained how the quality of clay as well as the way a piece is made make all the difference. I appreciate these bakers more now that I understand that," one reviewer wrote.
Buy it: $50 (originally $120); Zwilling
Best Petite: Pyrex Littles Toaster Oven Cookware
If you find yourself frequently turning to your toaster oven to cook small portions or reheat leftovers, these new casserole dishes are a must-have in your kitchen. They're made from the same sturdy, strong tempered glass that's dishwasher, oven, microwave, and freezer safe. The six-piece set includes two 18-ounce square dishes, two 24-ounce square dishes, and two 28-ounce square dishes.
Buy it: $40; Amazon
Best Non-stick: Rachael Ray Cucina Non-Stick Rectangular Cake Pan
Non-stick pans don't have to be the invariable black or dark gray. This non-stick casserole dish from Rachael Ray is a lovely latte with teal silicone grips. But the color isn't what makes this option so fantastic; it's what thousands of reviewers love about this pan: "It is truly a non-stick pan. Everything just slides right out with no messy pan to clean. The handles are nice too because they are heat resistant."
Other reviewers noted that the pans looks brand new even a year after buying, but the care recommendation is to hand-wash these pans instead of popping them in a dishwasher. If you like the rectangle version, there's a square dish, too.
Buy it: $26 (originally $34); Wayfair
Best Deep Dish: Emile Henry Modern Classics Rectangular Baker
Layered dishes like lasagna and salads can benefit from some extra space in a casserole dish, so if you frequently find these recipes on your menu, make room in your cabinet for this great deep-dish baking pan.
Emile Henry's rectangular baker is heat resistant up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and the glazed finish protects against scratches and sticking. (Some reviewers say it's so non-stick they don't use a spray or oil.) At three inches deep, this baker is actually deeper than the brand's Lasagna Pan. With a 10-year warranty, the price really is a bargain.
"This is a really lovely baker. I love the tall sides and the finish is like others have said - cleans up easily. I'm looking forward to using it often. I wish I'd had it years ago!" one reviewer wrote.
Buy it: $60; Sur La Table
Best Round: Staub 14.5-Inch Oval Baking Dish
Dishes like shepherd's pie and apple crisp are beautiful when served in oval and round casserole dishes, as are layered favorites like ratatouille and potato gratin. The shapely baking dish adds interest to buffets and holiday spreads, which makes it a beautiful addition to any bakeware collection. This Staub ceramic oval baker is coated in a scratch-resistant porcelain-enamel finish, and they're microwave and oven safe up to 572 degrees Fahrenheit. They can also safely be stored in the fridge and freezer, and they're dishwasher safe.
"I love Staub ceramics for so many reasons...the colors are gorgeous and they look beautiful on your table but I think my favorite is the confidence I have in their thermal shock resistance," one reviewer wrote. "I once had a lesser brand ceramic handle break off as I was removing my lasagna from the oven and have since replaced all of my bakeware with Staub so I never have to worry about that again."
Buy it: $70 (originally $100); Zwilling