20 Comforting Pot Pie Recipes
There's nothing quite as comforting as a classic pot pie, but dinner gets even more interesting when you take parts of the beloved chicken pot pie and switch it up with a variety of ingredients. Our collection of 20 pot pie recipes includes unique filling and sauce combinations like steak and Irish stout, lobster in a creamy sauce, or even pepperoni with marinara. So roll out some dough and get to cooking, because the whole family will enjoy these rich pot pies.
Grandma Carlson's Turkey Pot Pie
Steak and Irish Stout Pie
Easy Weeknight Tuna Pot Pie
"This recipe really surprised me, it was wonderful," says Jackie C. "I was honestly not expecting anything gourmet, and it isn't, but for simple ingredients that I normally always have on hand this is a wonderful dish."
Chili Cheese Dog Pot Pie
Chili cheese dogs are a delicious meal, but can end up being messy when feeding the whole family. Instead, whip up this easy casserole for all the flavor of your favorite dish, but none of the hassle.
Lew's Famous Lobster Pot Pie
Lobster is cooked in a seafood seasoning blend before being combined with veggies and a creamy sauce in this pot pie recipe. Need something a little easier on your wallet? Many reviewers had success substituting other seafood favorites like snow crab or shrimp for the lobster.
Beef Pot Pie
When you need to warm up on a cold evening, this hearty pot pie is just the ticket. Tender pieces of steak pair up with potatoes, carrots, and peas in a rich gravy.
Veggie Pot Pie
"This recipe is delicious. I would give it more than 5 stars if possible," says reviewer kdeeryhays. "As a vegetarian who lives in a house full of meat eaters, this recipe was a definite winner with everyone."
Jambalaya Pot Pie
Upside-Down Pizza Pot Pie
Pheasant Pot Pie
"This was great," says Michelle Butler. "We eat pheasant at least once a week and this is the first recipe where it actually tastes as good as chicken!"
Indian Samosa Pie
Chicken Parmesan Pot Pie
A pot pie twist on this Italian favorite, this recipe layers up chicken, homemade tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a tender crust sprinkled with Parmesan.
Mahi Mahi Pot Pie
Tofu Vegetable Pot Pie
This vegetarian recipe has all the pot pie flavors you've come to love, but none of the meat! Tofu adds a hearty texture and plenty of protein.
Tuscan Pot Pie
You only need six ingredients for this simple Italian-inspired meal. We couldn't have said it better than reviewer Manda, "This was a good, fast, cheap, and easy meal."
Salmon Pot Pie
Fresh salmon may be the star of this recipe, but other seafood favorites play supporting rolls. Clam juice, shrimp, and smoked salmon all add layers of flavor to this rich dish.
Bratwurst Pot Pie
This unexpected German twist on pot pie is sure to be a new family favorite. Beer brats combine with veggies in a creamy mustard sauce, before getting covered in crushed pretzels and baked to perfection.
Venison Pot Pie
Baked Chili Cornbread Pot Pie
Pizza Pot Pie
Combining the best of both worlds — deep dish pizza and pot pie — this hearty recipe is ready in under an hour. Customize with your favorite pizza toppings, and it's a sure winner.