9 Top Sicilian Dessert Recipes to Celebrate the Sweet Life

If you can't get to Sicily any time soon, you can still enjoy the sweet life of Sicily with this collection of the island's best desserts. Here we're featuring classic treats like Cannoli alla Siciliana, Sicilian Granita al Limone, Cassata alla Siciliana, and more.

01 of 09

Cannoli alla Siciliana (Sicilian Cannoli)

Cannoli alla Siciliana (Sicilian Cannoli)

These traditional Sicilian cannoli feature mixed peel and chocolate pieces in the filling and a sprinkle of crushed pistachios on top. "Not only do these little Italian pastries look and taste delicious, but this cannoli recipe stays true to the classic version" says Maria. "You won't be able to resist these! Fill the cannoli just before serving or the shells will get soggy."

02 of 09

Authentic Sicilian Granita al Limone

"Lemon granita is one of my favorite things about Sicily," says Buckwheat Queen. "It's easy to make at home if a trip to the island isn't possible. Using Meyer lemons, which tend to be sweeter than regular lemons, helps replicate the flavor of authentic Sicilian lemons. Serve as an after-dinner refresher or afternoon pick-me-up. And for a nice twist, add a small scoop to your iced tea, like they do in Sicily."

03 of 09

Cannoli Cheesecake

Cannoli Cheesecake
Cannoli Cheesecake. Allrecipes

Inspired by the flavors of a traditional Sicilian cannoli, this rich cheesecake's filling features sweet-and-creamy mascarpone and ricotta cheeses. "Bellissimo!" raves Cookin' with Lukie. "My Sicilian Grandmothers would have loved this cheesecake! This will be at the top of my cheesecake list from now on!"

04 of 09


Sicilian gelato is denser and creamier than ice cream. "This is a basic gelato recipe from my Italian mother-in-law," says OSTAFF1. "Use it as a base for your favorite flavors. Try adding vanilla, shaved chocolate or your favorite fruits. Experiment with desired flavors!"

05 of 09

Cassata alla Siciliana (Sicilian Cream Tart)

A beautiful sponge layer cake is filled with a light ricotta cheese filling. "Very nice dessert for a special occasion," says emb. "It can be made a day or two ahead of serving and kept in the refrigerator. I have made the frosting with rum as in this version or with chocolate and espresso coffee. You can change the additions to the filling to suit your tastes."

06 of 09

Sicilian Fig Cookies

Sicilian Fig Cookies
Sicilian Fig Cookies.

"A delicious fig-filled pastry," says Letricia. "You may substitute the figs with dried apricots or dates. Hazelnuts can also be used in place of the walnuts."

07 of 09

Sicilian Ricotta Cheesecake

Sicilian Ricotta Cheesecake.

This ricotta cheesecake is similar in style to an American cheesecake, only much lighter. "My husband loves the Sicilian Ricotta Cheesecake," says nara. "So smooth and with a delicate flavor."

08 of 09

Sicilian Easter Pie

Sicilian Easter Pie
Sicilian Easter Pie. FrancesC

"This is a recipe handed down from my Sicilian grandmother," says LINDASLUSCIOUSPIES. "Each family has their own way of baking the Easter Pie in the Old Country, and with our family and friends it was discussed at length, believe me! This pie is made the week before Easter and offered to guests for at least a week around Easter (it will keep that long). Traditionally, it is left in the pan which it is baked in and is served from the pan. Enjoy!"

09 of 09


Photo by Kims Cooking Now.

Folks really rave about the homemade shells in this cannoli recipe. "Special equipment is needed such as hollow, stainless steel cannoli tubes, a pasta machine, and a pastry bag to help make these cannoli come out just like the ones at Italian restaurants and bakeries," says Lydia Nacawa, the recipe submitter. Kim's Cooking Now gave the recipe 5 stars: "The shells are spot on!" she says. "This was my first time making cannoli shells and the taste and texture are perfect."

Was this page helpful?
You’ll Also Love